Five US shares a year, watch only.
The same rule on the S&P 500 made a season over against the S&P 500's , but it beat the index in only seasons, most of the gain came from three big years, and companies that went bust are missing from the test, which flatters it.
Five UK shares
a year.
All from calculated, fixed rules.
From 1 December to 31 March, the rule watches the FTSE 350 for shares that close above their highest close of the year to 30 November. After 31 March it buys the 5 that had risen most in the 6 months before their breakout and holds them for 12 months. No sign-up, nothing to pay.
Plan your trades START HERE
Pick the season you bought your first 5. New here? Choose "New user (starting fresh)". Remembered on this device, separately from the monthly Trader Launchpad list.
Split into 5 equal slots, always five ways, as the replay does. Your pot is remembered on this device and never leaves it. Arithmetic only, not advice on how much to invest.
£3 to buy, £3 to sell, 0.5% UK stamp duty on every buy and a 0.1% spread each way, as the replay assumes. Your broker's will differ.
Each slot can fall a long way: half the picks dip about 16% below their buy price at some point in the year.
This season's 5, for reference
This season's picks: season
Price changes are before dealing costs and stamp duty.
How season was picked
Each step narrows the field. The ranking only orders the breakouts; stars, bubble readings and news never change the picks.
Next in line
The last five years, replayed
The 5-year replay is UK only: the US list has none. See it on the UK view ›
US record, watch only
The same rule on the S&P 500, : £10,000 fresh each season, each season's change over 12 months in %, S&P 500 members at the time where prices exist, prices only.
It beat the S&P 500 in only seasons, and most of the gain came from three big years (). Companies that went bust or were taken over are missing from the test, which flatters it.
UK and US side by side, and why the UK is the tested rule (How it works) ›
- What this is: what the rule would have done, season by season, from to .
- Starting money: £50,000. Money not in the 5 picks waits in a FTSE 250 tracker fund.
- Same rule every season: the 5 picks are chosen by the rule from the prices known at the time. The rule itself was settled in (see Caveats).
- Compared with: the monthly Trader Launchpad list on the same £50,000, the FTSE 250 index, the FTSE 100 index and UK savings.
Summary
The 5-Year Replay against the benchmarks
The teal line is the Big Hitters account, against the monthly Trader Launchpad list, simply holding the FTSE 250, the FTSE 100 and UK savings.
Month-end values in pounds, starting £50,000 at the end of . Hover a month for the figures.
Every season
Each season the whole account is split equally across the 5 picks after 31 March and held for 12 months.
Caveats
£10,000 fresh each season
The same rule over every season since : £10,000 put in fresh each season and sold 12 months later, so one good or bad season doesn't carry into the next.
Show the earlier seasons,
The bad side
How it works
One rule, run once a year. Nothing is sold early.
This guide is for the UK rule; US is watch only.
What to do, in four steps
Decide how much you want to invest. It is split into 5 equal slots, one per share, with equal money in each. Each season the whole pot is split equally over the 5 new picks.
Type it into Your pot under Plan your trades on Big Hitters (UK view). It is always split five ways, and the box shows what you'd invest and how much per slot. For each of this season's 5 it gives today's price in £ and p, the shares a slot buys, the stamp duty and the costs; a new user sees this as a preview, until the new 5 appear after 31 March. It adds up the year's costs (5 buys and 5 sells) in £ and as a share of your pot. Whole shares only (ticked at first) rounds each slot down and shows the money left over. A note appears when a slot would buy less than one share, or when the costs reach 2% of your pot. Copy orders copies the 5 lines (ticker, shares, approx £) to place at the first open after 31 March. Your pot stays on your device. Arithmetic only, not advice on how much to invest.
Open Plan your trades on Big Hitters. Pick when you started, or New user, and it tells you what to do now and what comes next.
This Season's Picks shows the 5 the rule chose, ranked by their 6-month rise, each on a card like this one:
There is no separate breakdown page: the card, its marks and its News check fold-out are the whole story. Under the 5, How season was picked shows how each step narrowed the field, and Next in line lists the breakouts ranked just below them.
Buy all 5 at the first open after 31 March, with equal money in each. The next buy is after .
- 11 Dec – 31 Mar: the rule finds the breakouts. Nothing for you to do.
- 2After 31 Mar: buy the 5 strongest, equal money in each.
- 312 months: hold through the dips.
- 4After the next 31 Mar: sell, and buy the new 5 the same day.
The season
1 Dec – 31 Mar: find the breakouts.
After 31 Mar: buy the 5 strongest.
12 months: hold through the dips.
After the next 31 Mar: sell, and buy the new 5 the same day.
No stop-loss and no watching the screen. Hold all 5 for 12 months, even through falls: picks usually dip about 16% at some point in the year, and the rule holds through that. Nothing is sold early. Come back after for the new 5: This Season's Picks and Plan your trades on Big Hitters will show them.
Why this rule
The rule
One rule, the same every season, run once a year on the FTSE 350. Nobody picks the shares by hand.
- Start with the FTSE 350 members on 30 November.
- Note each share's highest close in the 12 months to 30 November.
- Between 1 December and 31 March, the first close above that high is its breakout.
- Rank the breakouts by their rise over the 6 months up to the breakout day.
- The top 5 are bought at the first open after 31 March, with equal money in each.
- Hold all 5 for 12 months, with no stop-loss, then sell after the next 31 March and buy the new 5 the same day.
What a breakout is
A breakout is a share closing above its 12-month high for the first time between 1 December and 31 March: it has just done something it hasn't done all year.
- 1The 12-month high: the share's highest close in the 12 months to 30 November.
- 230 November: the list is taken (the FTSE 350 members that day) and each high is fixed.
- 31 December to 31 March: the window. The rule watches every member's closes.
- 4The first close above the high is the breakout. A share with no close above it by 31 March has no breakout this season.
How the 5 are ranked
Every breakout is ranked by its 6-month rise: how much it rose over the 6 months up to its breakout day. The 5 biggest rises are bought. Bubble readings and news never change the order.
Why the FTSE 350
- FTSE 100: the 100 biggest companies on the London Stock Exchange by market value.
- FTSE 250: the next 250 by size. These are mid-sized companies, many of them less well known.
- FTSE 350: the two together. The lists are reviewed every quarter, so companies move up, down, in and out.
How each list did on its own: The tests, step 6 ›
Why 12 months and no stop-loss
The rule holds all 5 for 12 months, with no stop-loss and no early sells. Picks usually fall about 16% at some point in the year; the rule holds through that. Half the picks fall about 16% or more below their buy price at some point in the year; 7 in 10 fall 10% or more, and 4 in 10 fall 20% or more.
Run on the same breakouts, , £10,000 fresh each season:
- Holding 12 months, to the next 31 March, as the rule does: +£2,226 a year (22.3%), worst season −18%.
- Selling after 31 December: +£1,825 (18.2%).
- A 30% stop-loss: +£2,005 (20.0%).
- A 20% stop-loss: +£1,805 (18.1%), worst season −21%, so it didn't even make the worst year smaller.
The stop-losses gave up more than they saved, and the longer hold did better.
Lab test 26: the current rule, members at the time, cleaned prices, costs included.
What the marks mean
Over the bubble line The Bubble Checker reads it 2σ or more above its 10-year trend. It's shown only when a share is over its bubble line; a caution, it doesn't change the picks.
None of these change the 5 picks. The 6-month rise alone decides them.
Costs
The figures include 0.1% dealing costs each way and 0.5% UK stamp duty on every buy. Prices only: dividends would add to every line, the picks included.
The 5-Year Replay
The 5-Year Replay runs this rule season by season on £50,000 from the end of to . Money not in the 5 picks waits in a FTSE 250 tracker fund. The account would have grown to , against simply holding the FTSE 250 and the FTSE 100 (prices only). The rule was settled in after testing on these same years, so treat the replay as an upper estimate (see its Caveats).
The full guide
Big Hitters is information, not advice: whether you buy the 5, and with how much, is up to you. You can also just watch: the 5-Year Replay shows every season, good and bad.
Before your first trade (once)
- A share-dealing account for UK shares. Any UK platform that deals in FTSE 350 shares will do. Many let you hold them in a Stocks and Shares ISA, so gains are free of UK tax.
- Stamp duty: 0.5% UK stamp duty is charged on every buy of UK shares. The figures on this site include it.
- Dealing fees: your platform's charge for each buy and sell. The figures here count 0.1% dealing costs each way; a fixed fee per deal weighs more on a small pot, with 5 buys and 5 sells a year.
- Buying at the open: the rule buys at the first open after 31 March. Buy as close to that open as you can; your price will differ a little from the opening price used in the figures.
Each April, in order
- After 31 March, open This Season's Picks: the new 5 are there.
- Sell last season's 5 first.
- Then buy the new 5 the same day, splitting the whole pot equally: 5 equal slots.
- A share in both lists can just be topped up or trimmed to an equal share, which saves a little in costs.
- Then leave all 5 for 12 months: no stop-loss and no early sells.
Joining partway through a season
Plan your trades on Big Hitters asks When did you start?
- New user (starting fresh): your first 5 come after . Don't buy this season's picks now: they were bought on , and buying part-way through a season isn't how the rule works. Meanwhile: decide your pot, see how past seasons went in the 5-Year Replay, and check your broker deals in UK shares.
- Season (bought ): you hold this season's 5. Keep all 5 until the first open after , then sell them and buy the new 5 the same day.
Your choice is remembered on this device. Anyone who chose an earlier season moves on to the current one by itself.
The words
The tests
Every figure on this site is a replay of the fixed rule on past prices. This is how it was tested, and where the tests stop.
How we tested the rule on the FTSE 350
Today's FTSE 350 only holds survivors, so testing on it flatters any rule. We rebuilt each season's FTSE 350 from FTSE Russell's official change lists (every company added or removed since ), as it stood on 30 November.
For example, Games Workshop only joined the FTSE 250 in , after its shares had more than tripled. Testing the season on today's list would wrongly count it. Senior plc was in the index then, but later fell as much as and dropped out; on today's list it would vanish, and its losses with it.
The rule is set before the test and not changed after. Breakouts use closing prices up to that day; shares are bought at the next open after 31 March and sold at the first open after the next 31 March; costs are each way plus stamp duty on every buy.
From the same breakouts each season, pick 5 at random, times. Random sets averaged a season (); the rule made ; only of random sets did as well.
The 5 breakouts with the smallest 6-month rise made a season, about the same as random. So the ranking is doing the work.
We ran the same rule on each list alone, , £10,000 each season:
The biggest runners come from both lists. Most seasons the 5 picks are one or two big companies and three or four mid-sized ones, so leaving either list out loses some of the best.
Same rule, members at the time, prices only (lab test 25, ).
Stop-losses, selling after 31 December, skipping a weak season and the monthly market brake all made less than the rule: see the rule against other versions below.
- Missing companies: companies later taken over or bust have no prices. In the earliest seasons fewer than half the members have prices (about in ), rising to about by .
- Prices only: dividends would add to every line, the picks included.
- Hindsight: the rule was settled in after testing many versions on these same years. Treat the figures as an upper estimate.
- Prices were checked for data errors, such as share splits the data never adjusted for, before testing.
- Not real trades: these are replays on past prices. Past results don't promise future ones.
The rule against other versions
The current rule and other versions of it on the same breakouts, , £10,000 fresh each season:
| Version | A year |
|---|---|
| The rule | +£2,226 (22.3%) |
| 5 at random from the same breakouts | +£700 (7.0%) |
| The 5 smallest risers | +£670 (6.7%) |
| Selling after 31 December | +£1,825 (18.2%) |
| 20% stop-loss | +£1,805 (18.1%) |
| 30% stop-loss | +£2,005 (20.0%) |
| Skip the season if the FTSE 100 is weak at end March | +£1,549 (15.5%) |
| Monthly market brake | +£1,638 (16.4%) |
| FTSE 100 index | +£452 (4.5%) |
- The luck test: 5,000 sets of 5 shares picked at random from the same breakouts made 7.0% a year on average. Only 1 of the 5,000 did as well as the rule. The 5 smallest risers did no better than chance (6.7%).
- Stop-losses: both made less. The 20% stop-loss's worst year was −21%, against the rule's −18%, so it didn't even make the worst year smaller.
- Skipping a weak season: leaving the season out when the FTSE 100 was below its 10-month average at the end of March made 15.5% a year, against the rule's 22.3%.
- The monthly market brake (during the hold, sell all 5 after a month-end with the FTSE 100 below its 10-month average, and buy them back after a month-end above it) made the bad years smaller: worst year −12% (over , −16% instead of −43%). It is a trade-off: about £600 a year less for smaller bad years.
- Skipping shares over the bubble line: it looked better on past picks, but across all 2,443 UK breakouts the red ones did about as well as the rest, so we treat that as luck. The reading is a caution only; it never removes a pick.
- Using the stars: In earlier testing on an older version of the rule, using the stars to choose the picks did worse, so they never change the 5 and Big Hitters doesn't show them.
Lab tests 23, 25 and 26: the current rule, members at the time, cleaned prices, costs included.
UK and US side by side ()
The same rule on each market, £10,000 fresh each season, each season's change over 12 months in %:
Every season since : 5-Year Replay ›
In plain words: the averages are almost the same, but the UK gets there steadily, while the US makes almost all of it in three years (). The other eight US seasons averaged about , and a typical US season trailed the S&P 500.
The UK passed the luck test (only 1 of 5,000 random sets did as well); the US hasn't been put through it on full data. The US test is also missing many companies that went bust or were taken over (up to of members in the early years), which flatters it. That's why the UK is the tested rule and the US is watch only.
Lab re-check: the current rule, members at the time (US: S&P 500 members at the time where prices exist), in £, prices only, 12-month hold, £10,000 fresh each season.
Why the US is watch only
Our best explanation is who is watching. The FTSE 350 includes 250 mid-sized UK companies that fewer analysts follow, so when one starts a strong run, it often has further to go before the market catches up. The S&P 500 is 500 of the most closely watched companies in the world. Good news is priced in quickly, so most breakouts fade, and the rule only wins big when one theme runs hard for a whole year, as chip makers did in .
That gives an average much like the UK's but a far bumpier ride: in a typical season the US picks trailed the S&P 500. The US test is also missing many companies that later went bust, which flatters it. Until it's tested on complete data, we show it for watching, not buying.
The news check
Each of this season's 5 picks is checked against the last 30 days of news for a fixed list of events: a guidance change, a big earnings beat or miss, a major contract or partnership, a share offering, a run of analyst upgrades or downgrades, and the like. A News! stamp on a pick's card means something was found; click it for the News check fold-out under the card, which says what, with the headlines and their sources. It looks the same whether the news is good, bad or mixed; the fold-out gives the direction. No stamp means nothing notable, or no check yet.
The chip under the marks says it in a few words (amber for bad or mixed news); No news check yet means the share hasn't been checked. On Big Hitters a small News pill marks a stamped pick. Next in line shows news only when a check exists.
Information only: the news check never changes the picks.
Questions
Can I buy this season's picks now?
No. The rule buys only at the first open after 31 March. If you are new, your first 5 come after ; Plan your trades on Big Hitters shows the New user plan.
What if a pick falls a lot?
Keep it. There is no stop-loss and nothing is sold early. Picks usually fall about 16% at some point in the year, and the rule holds through that.
What if a share is in both last season's and the new 5?
A share in both lists can just be topped up or trimmed to an equal share, which saves a little in costs.
How much do I need?
Any amount: it is split into 5 equal slots. Stamp duty (0.5%) and your platform's dealing fees come out of it, and a fixed fee per deal weighs more on a small pot.
Do I have to watch the market?
No. Once a year, after 31 March: sell last season's 5 and buy the new 5. Nothing to do in between.
Does the news check change the picks?
No. It is information only. The 6-month rise alone decides the 5.
What about the US list?
It is watch only: the same rule run on the S&P 500 list. Its average is about the same as the UK's, but far less steady, it hasn't had the luck test on full data, and companies that went bust are missing from its test. See UK and US side by side.
Do past results promise anything?
No. The record and the replay are replays of a fixed rule on past prices, not real trades. The rule was settled in after testing on those same years, so treat them as an upper estimate.